Fill out the brief form below for access to the free report.
Richard Vedder, the eclectic Ohio University economist, was a standout panelist at the Bush Institute’s Immigration and 4% Growth conference at the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas in December 2012, and he’s working on a book on the subject to be published by the Institute later this year. But today in the Wall Street Journal, his op-ed tackles another part of the growth-slowdown conundrum: government policies that discourage people from working. Vedder’s piece brought to mind Edward Prescott, the Nobel Prize-winning economist who contributed a chapter to our book, The 4% Solution. Prescott has done ground-breaking research that shows how high marginal tax rates account for the fact that Americans work about one-third more than Europeans. The result is GDP growth in the range of a sickly 1.5 percent. But now, as Vedder points out, the U.S. has been growing for the past 12 years at an average of 1.8 percent, or about half our historic average. Have we caught the European disease? Vedder’s piece does not tackle the question of tax rates. Instead, he points to more direct causes: food stamps, Social Security disability payments, extended unemployment benefits, and Pell grants as incentives to stay out of the work force – or leave it. He makes a powerful case. For example, in 1990, only 3 million Americans received work-related disability checks from Social Security; today, 8.6 million get such support. And, not coincidentally, such generous policies on food stamps, disability, unemployment benefits, and subsidized education are where Europe excels. What makes Vedder’s piece important is the way he frames the argument. He starts with the GDP growth rate and tries to solve the mystery of why it has fallen. This is precisely the direction that research and policy must go. First define the problem (slow growth, which limits opportunity and prosperity); come up with solutions (constraints on disability payments, more smart immigration, better tax policy, etc.); and promote those solutions far and wide. As the Congress and the President head for a showdown on fiscal policy, with the debt limit looming, the essential question, again, must be: what should government do in the realm of taxing and spending that will encourage growth? There is powerful research, including Prescott’s, that shows that higher tax rates discourage investment and work. But what about the spending side? Recent experience has shown that higher government spending might have a short-term effect on growth, but such spending generally amounts to empty calories. The case needs to be made that, by cutting unnecessary spending the U.S. will, in the long run, grow faster, not slower – because money will be left in the hands of the private sector, which uses it more efficiently. Not always, but certainly most of the time. At any rate, the first principle is growth. We don’t have it, so how are we going to get it? Not by emulating Europe, which, more and more, we seem to find irresistible, but instead by being more like us.
James K. Glassman is the Founding Executive Director of the George W. Bush Institute and the interim Director of the Military Service Initiative.
He served as undersecretary of state for public diplomacy and public affairs from June 2008 to January 2009, leading the government-wide international strategic communications effort. Among his accomplishments at the State Department was bringing new Internet technology to bear on outreach efforts, an approach he christened “Public Diplomacy 2.0.”
From June 2007 to June 2008, Glassman was chairman of the Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG). He directed all non-military, taxpayer-funded U.S. international broadcasting, including Voice of America, Radio Free Europe, and Alhurra TV. Glassman was a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute in Washington, D.C., from 1996 to 2008, specializing in economics and technology.
He has been moderator of three weekly television programs: Ideas in Action and TechnoPolitics on PBS and Capital Gang Sunday on CNN.
Glassman has had a long career as a journalist and publisher. He served as president of Atlantic Monthly, publisher of the New Republic, executive vice president of U.S. News & World Report, and editor and co-owner of Roll Call, the Congressional newspaper. Between 1993 and 2004, he was a columnist for the Washington Post and the International Herald Tribune and continues to write regularly for Kiplinger’s Personal Finance and Forbes. Shortly after graduating from college, he started Figaro, a weekly newspaper in New Orleans. His articles on finance, economics, and foreign policy have appeared in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, the Los Angeles Times, and various other publications.
Glassman has written three books on investing, and in April 2012 was appointed to the Investor Advisory Committee of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. He was formerly a member of the Policy Advisory Board of Intel Corporation and a senior advisor to AT&T Corporation and SAP America, Inc.Full Bio
How Trade Spreads Holiday Cheer
It is projected that the average American household will spend more than $1,000 during the holidays this year.
Deporting Salvadorans May Lead to Economic Decline
We should think carefully about a policy whose major impacts are likely to be reductions in employment and economic activity here at home, and increased instability and lawlessness along our borders.
Bush Institute's Laura Collins Talks Immigration on Good Morning Texas
Last week, Deputy Director of Economic Growth at the George. W. Bush Institute Laura Collins spoke with Good Morning Texas about immigration myths. During the interview, Collins had the opportunity to set the record straight and address common misconceptions about legal immigrants living in America today. The segment was inspired from facts released earlier this fall by the Bush Institute in the third edition of America's Advantage: A Handbook on Immigration and Economic Growth. Watch the full Good Morning Texas interview here.